I'm not going to excuse what the other person said, re the whole broad thing, but I do sort of get where the person was coming from.
From what I can gather in the thread, a few old threads were bumped.
Anyways, I'm not going to tell you how to go about things but on a personal note, I tend to prefer people PM'ing me on old works if they want to give feedback rather than bumping threads.
Again though, that's just me. (And to clarify something, I'm not blaming anyone for anything. Just thought I'd clarify with Candrah and Nadja's posts)
If you're still looking for feedback, I'm a bit busy at the moment with just starting a new project and also having a bit of web writing to do, but I'm willing to comment on your work if I have chance.
I also remember you giving me feedback a long time ago, but I can't remember if I repaid the favour. I think I did, but it doesn't matter anyway. If they're old works you want feedback on though, I'll be pm'ing the feedback and I won't comment on them without being asked, because I figure people don't want feedback on old pieces.
Don't ask me how I remember these little details as well.
I just have a good memory I guess with regard to this sort of thing, yet I can forget to do something I was asked to do five minutes ago. (As funny as that sounds anyway.)
Anyways, I wouldn't naturally assume your work is poor due to no comments. I can relate with that though, as I'm sure we've all been there.